I’m With Her (But I’m In Love With You) Lyrics[Verse 1]
I spend this evening with this girl I've been seeing since you left
She wanted to eat in the same restaurant that we did
As she kissed me while I got the bill
Every butterfly in me was still
Oh, I'm with her but I'm in love with you
[Verse 2]
After we walked and she started to talk about romance
With my eyes at my feet and the cracks in the street, we held hands
I couldn't hold her as long because
It didn't fit mine like yours
Oh, I'm with her but I'm in love with you
[Chorus]
Oh-oh-oh-oh-oh
Oh-oh-oh-oh-oh
Oh-oh-oh, I'm with her but I'm in love with you
[Verse 3]
In the taxi, she shimmied right across the backseat next to me
The driver said we were the cutest couple that he'd seen
I smiled so she could see, but my heart would never agree
Oh, I'm with her but I'm in love with you
[Verse 4]
The man at the wheel said, "I know you, I play all your songs"
Then she started to sing with him the one I wrote about you
She sat on my knee and she asked, "Is this one about me?" while she laughed
Oh, I'm with her but I'm in love with you
[Chorus]
Oh-oh-oh-oh-oh
Oh-oh-oh-oh-oh
Oh-oh-oh, I'm with her but I'm in love with you
Oh-oh-oh-oh-oh
Oh-oh-oh-oh-oh
Oh-oh-oh, I'm with her but I'm in love with you
[Outro]
I'm with her but I'm in love with you